Can't turn off Sort Siblings

[kinook]

Move one of the siblings up and/or down to turn off sorting of siblings.

[FlagTech]

OK, but that seems uncharacteristically counterintuitive for UR. I'd expect clicking the menu item to turn it off....a wishlist item?

Thanks.

[kinook]

We thought it was the most intuitive behavior, since if sorted order isn't desired, multiple item(s) will usually be manually ordered into the desired locations.

The first time Sort Siblings is selected, it sorts alphabetically. The 2nd time, it sorts in reverse alphabetic order. It didn't seem intuitive that a 3rd time would "unsort" (which wouldn't have any obvious effect on the order), and it's less work to move the first item down, then up, if that's what you want (initially sorted but not retain sort order when changing item titles).

There is also an option -- Tools | Options | Trees | Alphabetically sort when adding children to new items -- that you may want to uncheck if you generally want unordered lists when importing.

[FlagTech]

Thanks, I appreciate the explanation, and I agree with (or at least don't disagree with) pretty much every other design aspect of UR that I've seen so far. But I'm going to disagree with you on this one.

I think it's bad human engineering when a menu item can be turned on (placed in a checked state) by clicking it but not turned off by clicking it again, and there's no readily apparent way to turn off sorting. It's the kind of thing about which new users may have to post a tech. support request.<g>

(The Help mentioned that clicking the menu item a second time reverses the sort order, but if there was a mention of how to turn off Sort Siblings I missed it.)

As for me, I'd be happier with some kind of three-state command: Sort ascending, Sort descending, Don't sort.

Thanks.